View Cart0 items / $0.00 USD

Pin Grading Guide

All enamel pins are filled and polished by hand. As a result, there may be small variations or slight defects from pin to pin. Please keep this in mind while buying!

That being said, all pins are personally inspected and sorted before shipping to ensure everyone receives the same standard of quality.

Pins are sorted into three grades: standard, seconds, and unsellables.

Standard Pins (A-Grade)

Standard pins are the highest grade that I offer. Since they are handmade, they may have minor cosmetic imperfections.

Examples of possible Standard Pin imperfections:

  • small buff marks or scuffs on the metal/enamel
  • minor metal discoloration
  • minor specks on the surface of the enamel

Seconds Pins (B-Grade)

Seconds pins have more noticeable flaws and are sold at a discount.

Examples of possible Seconds Pins imperfections:

  • smudges or staining
  • small unfilled areas
  • noticeable scratches on the metal and enamel
  • heavy oxidation of the metal
  • specks or pores in the enamel
  • bent posts/backings

Unsellable Pins (C-Grade)

Unsellable pins have major, noticeable flaws. These are not sold to customers unless requested, and are heavily discounted.

Examples of possible Unsellable Pins imperfections:

  • loose posts/backings
  • major unfilled areas
  • incorrect color placement
  • overfilled enamel

If you have questions about the type of pin you are receiving please feel free to contact me! I'm always happy to provide photo samples of specific pins to ensure that you get the pin quality you're looking for.